I starting stalking Jill over at
The Happiest Sad about nine/ten months ago. I don't think I was ever
gutsy enough to leave a comment
(I stalk a LOT of blogs and I don't want people I don't know to think I'm a creeper) but I enjoyed reading her posts. When I was deciding what I wanted to post during National Adoption Month a
specific post of hers came to mind. Before I post her work of genious
(and that is what it is)...let me give you a little background. In the adoption world, there are people who
love it and people who
hate it. I remember being surprised the first time I googled
"adoption"
and found page after page of people berating the women who had
"abandoned" their babies and calling the adoptive parents "baby
stealers" and my heart sunk when I read of adult adoptees who said they
wish they had been aborted instead of placed for adoption
(SERIOUSLY!). I remember wishing I could go back to my
blissfully ignorant
state where I thought everyone loved adoption and it was all sunshine
and rainbows. But now, I'm glad I've read the other side. It makes me
more aware and more prepared...knowing that there are still those people
out there. But it does make me
sad that someone had such a horrible experience with something that
can be SO wonderful.
Ok, so here is Jill's post. It is called
Cold Risotto. It is long, but
oh, so worth it. If after you read it you are left hungry for more you can read more on her blog,
The Happiest Sad.
Cold Risotto
Today,
I have a story for you. It's made-up but I think it's a good story. I
promise there's a point to it. Here it goes. (My sincerest apologies if
your name happens to be Susan. It's a lovely name.)
Once upon a time, a woman - let's call her Susan - went to a
restaurant. Susan was very, very hungry. Some people might have thought
she was stupid to go to a restaurant when most people cook for
themselves, but that was Susan's business, not theirs, and for one
reason or other, Susan was going to a restaurant for dinner.
Susan's waitress was very friendly right off the bat. She made Susan
feel welcome and kept her water glass full and took her order and
promised it would be out shortly. Excited and, as I said, very hungry,
Susan eagerly awaited her risotto. She was so hungry, she thought this
risotto was going to be the best thing in the world. As she waited, she
had visions of risotto dancing in her head and all she could think of
was how happy she'd be once the waitress brought out her dish.
Some time passed, and suddenly the waitress was getting as crabby as
Susan was. Finally, after half an hour or more, the waitress slammed
down a dish of cold risotto and the bill and stalked away. Susan was
stunned. And the risotto, in addition to being rather cold, was quite
possibly the most disgusting dish of risotto ever served in the history
of food.
Susan was, understandably, appalled. She complained to management. The
manager was appalled as well, and tried to explain things. Shortly
after Susan's order had been placed, the chef quit. The waitress
received a phone call from her boyfriend, who dumped her - on the
phone, and while she was at work! The manager assured Susan that her
dinner was an exception, not the norm. This was a top-notch restaurant
with a good reputation. He offered to comp the dinner and pushed a gift
card at Susan in the hopes that she would give them another try and
see that their restaurant was not as bad as all that.
But Susan was unable to get past her cold risotto experience. She told
every person she knew about it. She blogged about what a horrible
restaurant it was, and how no one should ever eat there. When people
mentioned to her that they'd eaten there and had a lovely time, she
railed at them that they must be stupid not to see what a terrible
restaurant it was, and she harassed those people repeatedly and with
great force about what a bad decision they'd made. She ridiculed them
for their naiveté. She found their personal blogs and left numerous
comments about what idiots they were to even consider eating at that
restaurant again. In Susan's opinion, this restaurant should be closed
down immediately and not allowed to open again until changes were made
to ensure that no one would ever be served cold risotto again - in
fact, they shouldn't even serve risotto. Susan decided to make it her
life's work to speak out against the restaurant, and she couldn't
understand why the whole world didn't join in her crusade.
Now, you're probably wondering why on earth I am blathering on about
snippy Susan and her cold risotto. Susan sounds like a real piece of
work, doesn't she? Because really, who could have such an ego as to
assume that if they had a bad experience somewhere, no one else should
even consider that place?
Let's change the subject for a second, and then I'll get back to Susan.
Sorry, that's a terrible segue. Here's a better one.

That is an awesome Segway.
Anyway.
I have a great experience with adoption. I think it's wonderful. I
might not tell the entire world to eat at this restaurant called
adoption, but if I knew someone was hungry and didn't know where to
eat, I would certainly tell them to consider eating there. I would tell
them about my experience so they would know that, even though it
serves up the occasional dish of cold risotto, eating out isn't a
hazardous thing. It can be, but it doesn't have to be.
But I have noticed that there are a number of Susans in the adoption
world - on-line, in any case, and they are just as snippy and
unyielding and very much against the institution that they feel wronged
them so much. They got cold risotto. And that's not fair, and I won't
argue that point. What I take exception to is these Susans (allow me to
apologize if your name happens to be Susan) who go on-line and tell
hungry people that they need to learn how to cook because restaurants
are inherently wrong. I don't like hungry people being told they're
going to get food poisoning if they eat out.
You know what? I can't stop these people. I know there are people out
there for whom adoption has not been a good thing. I feel sorry for
them. The things that have happened to some people are unfair, wrong,
and shouldn't happen to anyone. But I get tired of them insisting that
adoption is a bad thing, refusing to believe that it can be an amazing
and wonderful thing, simply because it wasn't for them.
Adoption was the best thing in the world for my little Roo. It was the
best thing in the world for my mother. And it was the best thing in the
world for probably close to 100 little children I can think of just
off the top of my head. I'm sure there are countless others for whom it
was also the best. We're all happy with our risotto. We are proof that
the restaurant isn't a bad place, that the risotto isn't always cold
and that, just the opposite, it's frequently the best dish on the menu.
Susan's risotto was bad, but that doesn't mean I'm going to let her
tell me that my risotto was a mistake and that I'm going to regret it
for the rest of my life and that I "lost" my appetite to risotto.
For every horrible, traumatic, food-poisoning story you hear about
adoption, there are probably ten thousand stories or the best dinner
ever that no one ever tells. Cold risotto makes for good news. A cozy
family meal interests no one.
Is adoption always the right, best, most wonderful thing in the world?
Nope. Because it involves people, and people are imperfect. But I think
each hungry person should be able to decide for him- or herself how
best to have dinner.